In today’s high-stakes sales environment, where leads are the lifeblood of revenue and pressure to perform is constant, one question lingers in boardrooms and sales departments alike: Should a sales manager sell?

This is more than a philosophical debate—it’s a strategic one. Some argue that sales managers must lead from the front, closing deals to build credibility and trust. Others maintain that their most critical role is to enable the team to sell more, not to sell themselves.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the intricate dance between managing, leading, and selling—and how to strike the right balance to ensure maximum sales performance, consistent lead generation, and long-term growth. This article is packed with keyword-rich insights and tactical strategies to help you determine the right path for your team.

Understanding the Core Role of a Sales Manager

At the heart of every high-performing sales team is a capable, committed sales manager. But what exactly is their role?

A sales manager traditionally handles:

Setting and communicating sales goals
Creating and executing sales strategies
Hiring and onboarding new sales reps
Coaching and mentoring team members
Tracking KPIs and sales metrics
Forecasting pipeline performance
Reporting to senior leadership

Where does selling fit into that list? In most cases, selling is not their core responsibility.

“A sales manager is like a coach. You don’t expect a football coach to score touchdowns—you expect them to train, guide, and lead the players to victory.”

The key is in enablement—not execution. But let’s explore further.

Should Sales Managers Carry a Quota?

The decision to assign a quota to a sales manager depends on various organizational factors:

Company size and team structure
Sales complexity and cycle length
The experience level of the sales team
Resource availability and leadership bandwidth

In startups and small teams, it’s not uncommon for sales managers to pitch in directly. However, in mature organizations, they should focus on strategic leadership.

The Pitfalls of Quota-Carrying Managers

Split focus between coaching and closing
Reduced availability for team guidance
Lead distribution conflicts among team members
Short-term wins at the expense of long-term development

The Hybrid Approach: Team Quotas

A smarter structure may be a team-based quota that rewards the manager for overall team success rather than individual performance. This supports coaching culture and long-term growth.

Block

Ready to Grow Your Business Faster Than Ever?

Grow My Business

STAY IN TOUCH

The Pros of Sales Managers Actively Selling

Despite the risks, there are moments when a sales manager’s involvement in deals can be beneficial.

1. Leading by Example

There’s nothing more inspiring than seeing a leader close a deal. It boosts morale and proves that strategies taught during coaching are effective in real-world scenarios.

2. Staying Sharp and Relevant

By participating in sales occasionally, managers stay up-to-date with buyer objections, industry changes, and product evolution. This enhances the quality of coaching provided.

3. Closing High-Value Deals

Sales managers can bring weight and authority to strategic deals or enterprise negotiations, especially when navigating complex objections or stakeholder dynamics.

Pro Tip: Reserve sales manager selling efforts for strategic opportunities, not routine sales cycles.

The Cons of Sales Managers Selling

Balancing leadership and selling is risky. Over-involvement in deals can cause serious challenges.

1. Neglecting Team Development

Time spent selling is time not spent coaching or mentoring. This neglect affects the performance of the entire team.

2. Undermining Team Trust

If managers take the best leads or jump into deals unnecessarily, it creates resentment and damages team morale.

3. Compromised Forecasting and Oversight

Over-focusing on personal deals causes pipeline oversight to suffer. That impacts revenue predictability and executive decision-making.

When Should a Sales Manager Sell?

There are specific cases where a sales manager’s involvement is both helpful and strategic:

To support reps during enterprise-level negotiations
To mentor junior reps through complex deal cycles
In startup settings where selling is a necessity
To demonstrate new product pitch techniques

When these situations arise, the manager acts more as a facilitator than a competitor.

Block

Manage Leads & Sales On The Go — Download MLeads Today!

Download The App

STAY IN TOUCH

Structuring Your Sales Team for Success

To strike the right balance between managing, leading, and selling, organizations must structure their sales teams with clarity and intention.

A. Define Clear Roles and Expectations

Document what is expected of sales managers vs. sales reps. Make sure all parties understand that selling is not a default responsibility of the manager.

B. Use Team-Based KPIs

Hold managers accountable for team success, not individual performance. Use KPIs like:

Win rate by rep
Lead-to-opportunity conversion
Average time to close
Team quota attainment

C. Leverage Smart Lead Routing Tools

Automate lead distribution using CRMs like:

This reduces internal conflict and ensures fairness in lead handling.

How Sales Managers Can Support Lead Generation Without Selling

Even if not closing deals, sales managers play a critical role in driving lead generation and improving pipeline health.

A. Enhance Conversion Metrics

By reviewing sales data and tools like Gong.io or Chorus.ai, managers can uncover trends and coach reps to optimize closing rates.

B. Improve Lead Qualification Training

Train reps to qualify leads better using frameworks like BANT or MEDDIC. Better qualification equals more closed deals.

C. Collaborate With Marketing

Align with the marketing team to ensure that:

Messaging is consistent
Lead handoff is seamless
Campaigns are informed by sales feedback

Recommended reading: How to Align Sales & Marketing Teams

What Makes a Sales Manager Effective Without Selling?

Great sales managers lead through enablement, not execution. The best ones possess:

Coaching mentality
Emotional intelligence
Data analysis skills
Motivational leadership
Strategic planning ability
Top-tier communication skills

Organizations should promote based on leadership ability, not sales records.

Alternatives to Selling: Coaching, Observing, and Strategizing

So if your sales manager doesn’t sell—what should they do instead?

A. Conduct Ride-Alongs and Call Reviews

Listening to sales calls provides rich coaching moments. Platforms like Gong help record and analyze calls for performance coaching.

B. Host Weekly Sales Strategy Sessions

Review the week’s leads, objection handling, and lost opportunities. This keeps the team aligned and constantly improving.

C. Build Sales Playbooks

Document best practices, successful pitch sequences, and objection-handling strategies to create repeatable success.

The Future of Sales Management: Enablement Over Execution

With the rise of automation, AI tools, and advanced CRMs, the role of the sales manager is rapidly evolving.

Modern sales managers focus on:

Coaching reps toward consistent performance
Implementing tools that accelerate lead handling
Predicting sales trends and adapting strategies
Scaling success across the organization

Forward-thinking organizations are investing in sales enablement platforms, internal L&D programs, and sales operations tools to support this shift.

Conclusion: Should a Sales Manager Sell?

In the debate of managing vs. selling, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer—but there is a clear trend. Sales managers are most effective when they empower the team, not when they chase their own quotas.

Sales managers should sell only when it serves a coaching or strategic purpose, not when it diverts attention from their core leadership responsibilities. By designing your sales structure around team empowerment, you unlock better performance, higher morale, and greater lead conversion.

The future of sales management lies in strategy, leadership, and enablement—not execution.